Attack on press freedom: BJP targets Hemant Soren govt over police raid on news channel60-day mega drive to implement NALSA schemes begins in Khunti’s Soundari villagePalamu police seize 495 grams of brown sugar worth around Rs 1 crore, one arrestedPalamu police seize truck carrying illicit khair wood worth Rs 10 lakh, driver arrestedWhy Chhath Puja is the soul of Bharat and how it boosts Bihar’s economyIPS Association backs DGP Tadasha Mishra, condemns Babulal Marandi’s remarks; BJP hits backCM Hemant Soren pays tribute to Birsa Munda on 151st birth anniversary at Ranchi memorialJharkhand marks 26th Foundation Day with ‘Run for Cleanliness’ across all 24 districts

Jharkhand HC declines to interfere in Bokaro land dispute, says Article 226 cannot decide disputed facts

The Jharkhand Story Network Ranchi, July 9: The Jharkhand High Court has dismissed a writ petition challenging an order of the Sub-Divisional…

Jharkhand HC declines to interfere in Bokaro land dispute, says Article 226 cannot decide disputed facts

The Jharkhand Story Network

Ranchi, July 9: The Jharkhand High Court has dismissed a writ petition challenging an order of the Sub-Divisional Officer (SDO), Chas, in a land dispute in Bokaro, holding that disputed questions relating to title, possession and encroachment cannot be adjudicated under Article 226 of the Constitution.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Justice Sanjay Kumar Dwivedi upheld the SDO’s order, observing that it had been passed to maintain law and order and that there was no material to establish arbitrariness or abuse of power warranting interference by the High Court.

The petitioner, Md. Shahid Raja, challenged an order dated April 10, 2012, by which the SDO directed deployment of police to restore possession of a parcel of land in favour of another claimant.

Stay informed. Get Jharkhand's top stories in your inbox.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

The petitioner contended that his father had purchased eight decimals of land in 1979, that the land had been mutated in his father’s name and that he had been unlawfully dispossessed pursuant to the SDO’s order.

The State submitted that the order had been passed solely to prevent a breach of law and order following complaints regarding possession of the property. During the pendency of the case, the disputed land was sold to another purchaser, whose name was subsequently mutated in the revenue records.

Advertisement
Advertisement

No adjudication of title under Article 226

The Court noted that the petitioner had referred to registered sale deeds in the writ petition but had failed to produce them despite stating that they would be placed on record.

It also observed that the petition involved disputed questions relating to land boundaries, possession and encroachment, which could not be resolved in writ proceedings.

The judgment said such disputes require adjudication through appropriate civil proceedings and not under the High Court’s extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Law and order within executive domain

Referring to Supreme Court precedents, the Court reiterated that decisions taken by administrative authorities to maintain public order are ordinarily not open to judicial interference unless there is clear evidence of arbitrariness, mala fides or patent illegality.

Finding no such infirmity in the SDO’s action, the Court dismissed the writ petition, holding that maintenance of law and order falls within the executive’s domain and that the impugned order did not warrant interference under Article 226 of the Constitution.

 

More from Breaking
Attack on press freedom: BJP targets Hemant Soren govt over police raid on news channel

Attack on press freedom: BJP targets Hemant Soren govt over police raid on news channel

November 16, 2026
60-day mega drive to implement NALSA schemes begins in Khunti’s Soundari village

60-day mega drive to implement NALSA schemes begins in Khunti’s Soundari village

November 16, 2026
Palamu police seize 495 grams of brown sugar worth around Rs 1 crore, one arrested

Palamu police seize 495 grams of brown sugar worth around Rs 1 crore, one arrested

November 16, 2026

Stay informed. Get Jharkhand's top stories in your inbox.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

About the Author

Suman Shrivastava