Khunti to hold National Lok Adalat on December 12; pre-Lok Adalat hearings underwayBJP questions Hemant Soren govt’s move to convene special Assembly session on MMDR ActJIADA plans ₹4.09-crore infrastructure revamp of Sudna Industrial Area in MedininagarRainfall activity to ease in Jharkhand from November 24; morning fog to persistFire breaks out in Steel Express coach between Ghatshila and Chakulia; passengers evacuatedPalamu police seize 288 cans of illicit beer hidden in pomegranate cartons on bus to BiharBabulal Marandi seeks CBI probe into sexual assault of prisoner at Hotwar JailJharkhand govt agrees to release 26 life convicts after review of 73 cases

Jharkhand HC denies relief to CISF officer for casteist remarks

THE JHARKHAND STORY DESK   Ranchi, Jan 21: In a recent order, the Jharkhand High Court clarified that the previous exemplary conduct…

Jharkhand HC denies relief to CISF officer for casteist remarks

THE JHARKHAND STORY DESK

 

Ranchi, Jan 21: In a recent order, the Jharkhand High Court clarified that the previous exemplary conduct of an officer cannot serve as a basis for altering the severity of a punishment imposed by a disciplinary authority, a decision later upheld by both the appellate authority and a single-judge bench.

The High Court was considering an appeal filed by a former Assistant Commandant of CISF, BSL, who had been accused of making comments about the caste of an inspector posted in his office.

Stay informed. Get Jharkhand's top stories in your inbox.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

The case was heard by a bench of Chief Justice M.S. Ramachandra Rao and Justice Gautam Kumar Choudhary in the Jharkhand High Court.

During the proceedings, the court stated that it could not overlook the fact that the appellant was an employee of CISF, a disciplined force. The court emphasized that when the allegations are serious, as in the present case, leniency is not warranted.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Also Read- SC dismisses Jharkhand govt’s plea in Deoghar airport case

Case background

The appellant, while serving as an Assistant Commandant in CISF, was accused of committing misconduct in 2008 by making comments about the caste (SC) of an inspector in front of an ASI.

In 2009, the appellant again made an insulting and intimidating comment with the intention of humiliating the same person, referring to his caste in front of another ASI.

The appellant retired from CISF, but was informed that an inquiry would continue against him even after his retirement, under Rule 9 of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Challenging the charge memo and initiation of departmental action, the appellant filed a petition. The allegations against the appellant were proven, and a penalty was imposed, which included a 20% deduction from his monthly pension on a permanent basis and the forfeiture of his entire gratuity. Following this, the appellant filed a departmental appeal, but it was dismissed.

Also Read- Min. temp. witnesses rise across Jharkhand 

His appeal against the order of the appellate authority was also dismissed. Following this, the single bench’s order was challenged in the double bench.

The words ‘gross misconduct’ used in the charge memo also imply that the misconduct is of a ‘serious’ nature, meaning it is of an extremely grave nature. The appellant cannot benefit from the absence of the term ‘serious misconduct’ in the charge memo. In this regard, Rajni Kant Patra had filed a petition in the High Court.

More from Breaking
Khunti to hold National Lok Adalat on December 12; pre-Lok Adalat hearings underway

Khunti to hold National Lok Adalat on December 12; pre-Lok Adalat hearings underway

November 21, 2026
BJP questions Hemant Soren govt’s move to convene special Assembly session on MMDR Act

BJP questions Hemant Soren govt’s move to convene special Assembly session on MMDR Act

November 21, 2026
JIADA plans ₹4.09-crore infrastructure revamp of Sudna Industrial Area in Medininagar

JIADA plans ₹4.09-crore infrastructure revamp of Sudna Industrial Area in Medininagar

November 21, 2026

Stay informed. Get Jharkhand's top stories in your inbox.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

About the Author

Suman Shrivastava