Jharkhand assembly marks 26th Foundation Day; Hemant Soren calls for greater accountabilityJharkhand launches Samaveshi Ajeevika Yojana to help 16,000 ultra-poor households escape povertyNPU detects AI-generated fake joining letter for junior clerk postChiyanki airstrip faces major infrastructure gaps ahead of proposed UDAN operationsKhunti to hold National Lok Adalat on December 12; pre-Lok Adalat hearings underwayBJP questions Hemant Soren govt’s move to convene special Assembly session on MMDR ActJIADA plans ₹4.09-crore infrastructure revamp of Sudna Industrial Area in MedininagarRainfall activity to ease in Jharkhand from November 24; morning fog to persist

Too many coffee breaks: SC criticises High Court judges, proposes performance review

THE JHARKHAND STORY NETWORK   New Delhi, May 14: The Supreme Court of India has raised serious concerns over the delay in pronouncement…

Too many coffee breaks: SC criticises High Court judges, proposes performance review

THE JHARKHAND STORY NETWORK

 

New Delhi, May 14: The Supreme Court of India has raised serious concerns over the delay in pronouncement of judgments by High Courts, questioning the work ethic of some judges who allegedly take excessive breaks during court hours.

The apex court’s remarks came during a hearing on Monday in a case where four convicts were forced to remain in custody for nearly three years after their appeals were heard and reserved by the Jharkhand High Court — but never decided.

Stay informed. Get Jharkhand's top stories in your inbox.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

A Bench comprising Justices Surya Kant and N. Kotiswar Singh did not mince words as it turned its attention to systemic inefficiencies within the judiciary.

“We want to examine a larger issue: What is the output of the High Courts? How much are we spending on the system, and what are we getting in return? What benchmarks are in place?” Justice Kant observed.

Advertisement
Advertisement

He continued: “Some judges work incredibly hard and make us proud. But others are unfortunately disappointing. We’re hearing about judges taking tea breaks, coffee breaks, this break, that break. Why not work continuously, with only a lunch break? It would lead to better performance and better outcomes.”

Delayed Justice, Lost Liberty

The Supreme Court was hearing a petition filed by four convicts whose appeals had been reserved by the Jharkhand High Court two to three years ago. After intervention from the apex court, the High Court recently delivered its verdict—acquitting three of the convicts and issuing a split decision in the case of the fourth. All four were ordered to be released from custody.

Also Read: Jharkhand govt-run English-medium schools shine in first CBSE-aligned exams

Advertisement
Advertisement

Advocate Fauzia Shakil, representing the petitioners, thanked the Court for its intervention, noting that the case touched on the fundamental issue of personal liberty. “They could have walked free three years ago had the judgments been delivered on time,” she said.

Justice Kant expressed regret over the delay, affirming the Court’s disappointment.

Court Seeks Wider Judicial Accountability

In light of the delays, the Supreme Court signalled its intention to evolve mechanisms for ensuring timely judgments, reaffirming that High Courts must adhere to the timelines already prescribed by the apex court.

Last week, in connection with the same matter, the Court requested data from all High Courts on judgments that have remained reserved without pronouncement since before 31 January 2025.

More from Breaking
Jharkhand assembly marks 26th Foundation Day; Hemant Soren calls for greater accountability

Jharkhand assembly marks 26th Foundation Day; Hemant Soren calls for greater accountability

November 22, 2026
Jharkhand launches Samaveshi Ajeevika Yojana to help 16,000 ultra-poor households escape poverty

Jharkhand launches Samaveshi Ajeevika Yojana to help 16,000 ultra-poor households escape poverty

November 22, 2026
NPU detects AI-generated fake joining letter for junior clerk post

NPU detects AI-generated fake joining letter for junior clerk post

November 22, 2026

Stay informed. Get Jharkhand's top stories in your inbox.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

About the Author

Suman Shrivastava